This was number 41 for me. I decided against attempting all 3 because I'm lazy. Guess I'll have to go back for Wilson / El Diente - Message me if you'd like to meet up!
I wanted company for this one, and brought along a partner who had never summited a 14er, but is a decent rock climber and has hiked biggish stuff around the world. We arrived at our camp spot, right by the trailhead, the night before and got our start at 5:10 AM, about 30 mins later than we planned. The Navajo Basin trail was a great way to start and end the day - It's not mellow, but it's not quite as steep as some of the trail starts I've done (Belford/Oxford, Little Bear), so you get a nice warm up and cool down. The trail continues on in a way that I think is very favorable to gaining elevation without exhausting yourself, right up until the end. Then the BUSINESS starts.
The first ridge to the second is not too bad - Some loose rock, mild exposure, but easy enough. I'd call it difficult class two.
From the second ridge and on (when you switch over to the north side of the mountain), expect extreme exposure and very loose rock. Right at the start of the north side, the trail is very very difficult to identify. I'm pretty convinced that a rock slide or something has destroyed what was the vague trail when the route description was first written, because there is no way that this traverse could be called class 3. It was, in my opinion, the very definition of class 4. It's important to note that Photo 9 in the route description shows that you should go between two rocks, which, when you are up there, implies you should stay high. DON'T - Go down a bit and begin your traverse, but still expect a difficult, technical, very exposed bit of climbing. My partner was having the time of her life. I was scared, making slow slow careful moves.
The route finding on the way up was very difficult for us and kept the whole thing around class 3. On the way down, it was much easier to follow the trail and keep things a bit easier. But, I still can't recommend enough testing every single rock you put your weight on - I found it very loose and unpredictable.
The final section (downclimb, gash, summit) looks very intimidating, and can certainly be difficult to keep below class 4, but in my opinion was faaaarrrrr less technical and exposed than the first difficult section. At this point, my partner got quite intimidated and we sat at the false summit for quite a while deciding whether to push on. It turned out to be not as bad as it looked.
The way down, as I mentioned, was easier. When you get back to the Navajo Basin trail, it's a pretty nice descent - one of the most mild I've been on in recent climbs.
All in all, what a tough-ass mountain. Much harder than I expected based on the route description.